Friday, 20 November 2026

Dithering or Dashing? Giving 'Honours of War' a try..

Last week I was pleased to welcome my old gaming friend Tony to my place for a wargame, which involved a few 'firsts' for me. These were (i) the first 'face to face' game I've hosted since probably the 1980s(!)   (ii) the first 'conventional' table-top wargame ( I am excluding Dominion of.. which I'd call a mini-game) with the vintage Seven Years War collection I acquired last year,  and (iii) a first try-out of Keith Flint's Honours of War rules, which I have owned for a while but never quite got around to playing. 

Sensibly enough, I thought it best to start with the first suggested scenario in the HoW rulebook, which is entitled The Combat of St. Ulrich and recommended by Keith Flint  -  'its small size means it would be a good way to get to know the rules'. With only four or five units on each side and quite simple terrain, I had no problem setting up the table and finding enough forces - in particular my recently organised Russian contingent is ideal for this scenario. Having chosen them, the logical historic opponent would be the Prussians, so that was an easy choice.  

I set up the game on my dining table, which extends to 5 feet 6 inches by 3 feet  (roughly 170 x 90cm). It was a good chance to get out some very vintage scenery in the shape of the Bellona bridge and river sections. I think we managed a pleasingly simple 'old school' sort of look : 

 

The scenario suggests a 'Red'  force of 4 units defending the bridge at St Ulrich, and a 'Blue' force of 5 units attacking it.   The rulebook has sections on 'National Differences', which mentions that in battles between the Russians and Prussians,  Frederick the Great's Army 'chose to attack on each occasion' - so it seemed appropriate to make Prussia 'Blue' and Russia 'Red'.  Accordingly the forces were recruited and deployed  as follows: 

Prussian attackers 

 Prussians  5 units, Army Break Point = 2  (so losing 2 units means losing the game) 

    - Infantry Brigade ( 3 battalions )  a battalion from each of 

            - 9th Infantry 'Jung Kleist'

            - 44th Regt 'Jung Kenn' Fusiliers 

            - 41st Regt 'Wied Zu NuWied' Fusiliers, 

            - and one medium artillery battery. 

    - Independent unit 

            - 1 regiment of Dragoons ( I have not yet identified  which historic                                                                 regiment they might represent ) 

We made a slight deployment error - the scenario map specifies that the gun battery should be limbered and arriving along the road behind the battalion (41st Fusiliers ) in column. But it made very little difference to events. 

..and Russian defenders
 Russians  4 units, Army Break Point = 2  

    - Infantry Brigade (2 battalions)   one each from the following regiments :

        -  Butyrskiy Infantry

        -  3rd Grenadiers 

        - and one medium artillery battery (on loan from Austria, no Russian guns being available yet)

  - Independent unit 

            - 1 regiment of cavalry  - Slobodskiy Hussars 

Units in HoW have different 'classes' (Superior, Standard or Inferior), and the National Differences allocate these. The Russian Hussars are rated Inferior as battlefield cavalry, and that gave the Prussian Dragoons (Standard) an advantage - hence for balance, I gave the Russians a unit of Grenadiers, rated Superior. All other units on both sides were classed as Standard.   Brigade commanders can be 'Dithering', 'Dependable' or 'Dashing' -  I do like Keith's terminology - decided by die rolls, and both sides rolled up  Dependable leaders for their infantry brigades, while Independent units (i.e the Cavalry)  are always  treated as Dependable.   Each side has a  Commanding General - this represents the player, and another nice touch is that there's no rating for them. You are not limited by some arbitrary characteristics imposed on your own character, but you do have to deal with the characters of the subordinates who you give commands  to, which seems exactly right, 

And so to battle:  which I have to admit, only lasted 3 turns!  The turn sequence has movement first, and there's a die roll for 'movement intiative' i.e who goes first, and unsurprisngly the Prussians have a 'plus 1'  on that roll, and the plodding Russians a 'minus 1' .  On turn one the Attacker always has initiatve anyway.   I suggested Tony take the Prussian attackers  (General von Tomas?) as they'd be more fun!  

The movement phase sees each side move alternately, one Brigade or Independent Unit at a time, but each brigade/unit has to roll for 'Command Performance' - how keen are they to move? - and this is dependent on the Brigadier's rating. There can be a range of outcomes from 'Feeble' (forced retreat!) to 'Admirable' (double moves if desired!).  At this point, Tony's dice deserted him; the Prussian cavalry happily advanced, but the infantry brigade were 'Poor' and refused to move! Clearly his Brigadier was still at breakfast.. My Russian infantry stood their ground, while my Hussars optimistically advanced to meet the enemy Dragoons.  

Turn 1 : cavalry move up, Infantry don't! 
 

Firing next - there's an initiative roll for that too, Prussians get +1 again. Players then alternate firing by Brigade or Independent Unit, and of course the winner gets first go. On this turn both sides artillery let fly,  and I scored a hit on the 41st Fusiliers, rather vulnerable in their march column. In general, units can take 2 hits with no negative effect, but will start to suffer on 3 hits, become demoralised and forced to retreat on 4 hits, and are 'Done For' (another nice bit of  terminology) at 5 hits.    Next was Melee phase, but  obviously there was no melee - finally 'Rally Phase', which allows units who are not too close to the enemy to 'rally off' hits - 41st Fusiliers were thus  able to recover.

After that slow start, the Prussians got into their stride on Turn 2, winning movement initiative and successfully ordering all units forward.  Both sides' cavalry advanced - Tony's Prussian Dragoons charged, and my Russian Hussars  were able to counter-charge. Contact! 

Turn 2: Prussian advance, cavalry contact..

The Prussian infantry were able to deploy into line and advance to the attack ( I think the brigade rolled 'Admirable' -  double moves!), but this brought the 41st Fusiliers within canister range of the Russian guns - the dice were with me now, and the Fusiliers ended up with  4 hits (see the small dice placed with them) , and forced to retreat.  I should really have got some cotton wool out for a bit of 'realism' when units fire!  In the  cavalry melee, my optimism was misplaced, and the Slobodskiy Hussars were promptly 'Done For'!  so that was one 'Break Point' to Tony, and my right flank at severe risk! 

end of Turn 2 : Russian flank 'in the air'! 

 Things didn't look great for my Russians at this point, with those  evil-looking Dragoons about to sweep around my right flank, even if the  Wied Zu NuWied Fusiliers had been forced to retire.  

On Turn 3, Tony again won the movement initiative,  sending the 9th and 44th Infantry determinedly  forward while their comrades in the 41st paused to rally and re-organise. Leading the charge, IR44 Jung Kenn crashed into my  Butyrskiy Infantry, with IR9 Jung Kleist in support and aiming to outflank me.

Prussian infantry - charge! 
 

But then, two crucial die rolls went in my favour - first my Infantry brigade got double moves, and I threw caution to the winds ('let's see what happens' -  Tony to his credit said he would have done the same thing) and ordered my Grenadiers to charge the re-forming Prussian 41st Fusiliers.  This was highly risky with  those Dragoons on the open flank - but the dice were not with Tony, the Dragoons promptly failed their command roll, and stopped still! Presumably slow to recover order after their melee with the Hussars? 

and Russian Grenadiers - charge! 
 

So now, it was all down to the melee rolls.. and poor Tony's dice deserted him! Under a 'Crossing Fire' rule, my artillery were able to score hits on the charging 44th Fusiliers, but couldn't stop them charging home,  However, Tony's die rolls in the ensuing melee were catastrophic, and IR44 were promptly 'Done For' and routing! 

IR44 routed.. 
 In the melee between my 'Superior' class Grenadiers and the re-forming 41st Fusilier (a re-forming unit charged by an enemy unit  cannot fire, and count as attacked in flank or rear), things were only going to go one way. The dice did not come to Tony's rescue;  the Fusiliers started on 4 hits and ended up with about 7 - well and truly 'Done For'.

and IR41 'Done For' 
And that was that, after just three  turns. With the Prussians having 2 units 'Done For', they reached their Army Break Point and the game was over. Quite a turn-around in that last turn; how different it could have been if those Dragoons had got moving! 

'von Tomas' took defeat well!

Despite its brevity, I was well pleased with the game and in particular the Honours of War rules. They are relatively simple, and clearly-written; I had rather hurriedly read through them just once the day before, and we played the game by initially stepping through the turn sequence and reading through each section as we went. We very soon picked-up what we needed to remember, and I liked the use of just a single dice for all die rolls ( mostly a 'D6', with occasional use of  an Average Dice ) - 'buckets of dice' are fun, of course, but can be a bit cumbersome, I think. As I've stated already, I really liked the use of terminology such as the 'Dithering/Dependable/Dashing' commander ratings and 'Done For' units, they rang true nicely for the period and for a slightly 'old school' feel. 

The Command and Control system of rolling a die for each brigade when attempting to order them worked well, and players of the Black Powder rules family  (of which Tony is a fan) will feel comfortable with it. The mechanism is only  slightly different, uses the same concept of combining commander's ability with die roll  and gives a similar range of outcomes, from granting  multiple moves  to complete standstill or even retreat! In our game, this command and control 'friction' element played a significant, if perhaps not decisive, roll and gave a nice level of uncertainty (those Dragoons again!).    Combat was quite fast and furious, especially melee 'continue fighting rounds of melee in the same turn until one or both sides retreat, are Done For and rout'   ( one turn represents about 10 minutes, so this seems about right ),  but there is scope for rallying off hits and bringing battered units back into action. In larger games, I assume this will give a satisfying level of units being 'chewed up' in combat but still recoverable if pulled back,  and encourage the maintenance of sufficient reserves.  

For such a small game, I suppose I may have gone into a little too much detailed description here, but I wanted to give a fair  idea of the rules to anyone who doesn't know them (I suspect I may be very late to the party with HoW, I admit!)  and give myself the opportunity to 'think aloud'  about how I found them to work. So I hope you don't mind - if you've read this far, I assume you don't!       

So a good game, and quick - plenty of time for quite a lot of chat and a good lunch at a local cafe (thanks Tony!), it was as much a social as a gaming occasion. I'm quite encouraged by the game, and will try to organise something a bit bigger - I see the next suggested scenario in the rulebook pits 10 units against 11, that should be pretty achievable.   I'm thinking Austrians joining Russians against a larger Prussian force - watch this space.. Many thanks of course to Tony for his excellent company and his patience with a new set of rules - I hope he enjoyed the day, and you have enjoyed reading about it. 

Quite a lot of 'real life' is intruding at the moment, but I hope to get back some hobby time next week - I'd better get the re-basing/painting production line restarted, and perhaps report on that. Until then keep well, everyone.  

No comments:

Post a Comment