Thursday, 12 October 2023

Another Other Partizan Report

Last Sunday I hit the road to sunny Newark, and attended 'The Other Partizan' show. A thoroughly enjoyable day was had, as expected.  Plenty  of interesting and impressive games to see, and I took some photos which I will show here. A great bonus was being  also able to meet my old friend Dave 'St Cyr on Wheels' and his wife; we had not met in person in many months since they moved to darkest Northampton, so really good to see them. Greetings Dave!

Now I have to admit that it's a fair old drive to the show, and I didn't really get going early enough - did not reach the venue until 12:30, and the show finished at 4pm - so it was a bit of a rush around towards the end. As a result, I probably missed quite a few good games, especially in the 'participation zone'. So this is by no means a comprehensive report - but what I did see was all good. I'll show them more or less in the order that we toured the room: 

1st Corps group put on a large game portraying The Defence of Calais, 1940 in 28mm, using Battlegroup rules, I think. Very impressive, the 'teddy bear fur' looked good - it reminded me of real colour pictures of Panzers on the Russian steppe - and the backdrop using printed railway was a lovely piece of work

1st Corps: Calais 1940

 
The Brens are coming..

Panzers on the march

and a rather effective backboard

More 28mm WW2 and 1940 from Chesterfield Old Boys, this time Beda Fomm in the desert :


I always like to see  a nice aircraft model flying over the table, it seems to be rather a trend in fact, and this game had a great example, this CR42 


Newark Irregulars showed their game of Gainsborough, 1643 also in 28mm :

good scenery, and a lovely big cavalry fight!

The 'Anti-Alchemists'  showed their 'Biscotti War, Garibaldi vs. Bourbon in 1860' , a fictional encounter set  during Garibaldi's invasion of Sicily,  using 28mm figures ( Gringo 40s ) and Sharp Practise rules.

Sicily 1860..

 
Garibaldi's Redshirts vs. Bourbons ( and an unfortunate cow )

I especially liked that their information sheet even gave brief historical details of the two types of biscuits! 

Derby Wargmes Society gave us 'Crossing the Berezina 1944' - WW2 in 20mm:

Berezina '44: I liked the forested terrain
 

The Iron Brigade provided more forestry, plus spectacular fortifications in 'Winter is Here' - a Game of Thrones ( sort of ) encounter in 28mm using Dragon Rampant rules. A neat trick was to use mirrors as the backboard, so it looked twice as long!


   

Boondock Sayntes provided probably the most spectacular single terrain piece - a Fortress in their Indian-set game 'Laisot 1785 and the rise of Benoit de Boigne' 

'a mighty fortress...'

and interior - modellers clearly just got a bit carried away!

Equally colourful troops made a beautiful setup

The name de Boigne  interested me, I checked later and realised I have owned  a book about him for at least 20 years ( Fountain of the Elephants by Desmond Young ) and never read it! I must rectify that promptly, from the explanation by the 'Sayntes' he will be well worth reading about.

 Old Pikey's Gaming Group had a very large layout for their 20mm Cold War game 'Operation Resolute' - the obligatory seething mass of Soviet armour, plus some more fun aircraft overhead.  Being at the end of the hall, it also afforded a good view of the whole room, so you can get an idea of the extent of it ( and also the demographic, I'd say. That's one of the Helion chaps on the left, I think.. )

hmmm.. Soviet armour in a bottleneck?


Gothenburg Gamers, who I think had come all the way from Scotland, showed a nice 28mm 'Crimean War' game - but not actually set in Crimea, as this depicted an engagement between Russians and Turks, a reminder that the Crimea was just part of a wider conflict. If I were the Turks here, I wold have been quite nervous facing this Russian column of attack ( and Dave, I think that's you.. )  

Quantity has a quality of its own.. 

 

Bramley Barn Wargames Club put on an interesting game - 28mm Elizabethan period, English vs. Irish.  They used a set of rules, Irregular Wars, which are aimed at re-creating 'smaller actions so common  at the fringes of the European world'.  


    

In this case, the 'irregular' but highly motivated Irish versus the 'regular' English Pike and Shot, whose ranks were likely to be stuffed with 'pressed' ex-convicts, poorly trained and motivated - though the English Demi-Lances shown here  would be the toughest unit on the field. All this very well explained by the Bramley Barn chaps, I thought it  made for an exemplary 'demonstration' game, in an interesting  and unusual period setting. 

Demi-Lances : Tudor England's  Panther Tanks?

Another really good-looking smaller game was from The Legion of Blokes -  'The Race to Caen' , described as 'Epic Scale WW2' , cleverly using 6mm figures with ( I think )  2mm scenery, and the whole thing in a case which folded up for transport! Really neat idea. The 'Epic' part was that it actually depicted a large area of the battlefield - if I remember right, the Blokes said this was all three British/Canadian beaches, and one or two figure stands represented a battalion. This was a great little big game, excellent stuff  ( and prize for top club/group name, which could equally work as the name of a show, perhaps? )

The (very) PortableWargame
 

Grimsby Wargames Society gave us a large WW1 game,  The Battle of Hargicourt featuring the 'Grimsby Chums' , set in August 1918, I think.  A splendid layout featuring another rather nice aircraft in the form of an Albatros DVa ( albeit going down in flames! ). I liked the idea of featuring a unit from their local area - high  time I  researched the history of the Suffolk Regiment?

Grimsby Pals - and Dave photo-bombing me again

 

 

The Rime of the Ancient Aviator?

Having recently visited Shropshire I was interested to see the Shrewsbury Wargames Club's Siege of Stokesay Castle (1645?), ECW in 28mm.  The castle made another 'trophy' piece of scenery to rival the Indian fortress, but I didn't really get  a decent photo. The figures were equally nice, though : 

 

Medway AD43 from Forest Outlaws and Kallistra looked impressive, and perhaps unsurprisingly was a good demonstration of how good Kallistra's Hexon terrain can look when used on a large scale. My own Hexon setup is usually 9 by 9 hexes, which would fit into this table about 6 times - but I can dream!

Medway AD 43 in 15mm

 

Medieval shipping made several appearances at the show :  (1) The Bodkins 28mm Breton War of Succession, Hennebont 1342


and -of course - (2) Andy Callan with 'Never Mind the Boathooks' 

Another minor trend was clearly Zulu Kraals : (1) Cramlington Wargames Group's Battle of Inyzane River 1879  

and (2) The Gentlemen Pensioners 'Death in the Donga - the Prince Imperial in Zululand 1879'

Zulu games, sir - at least two of 'em

Now I'm afraid I'm very old-school in one respect, I am not really bothered with  Sci-Fi or Fantasy games - but how about this for Sci-Fi terrain?  I think it's 'The Invasion of Skaro' by Chesterfield Open Gaming Society,  using Xenos Rampant: I suspect that this featured very ingenious use of 'found objects' and an awful lot of silver spray paint, and it looked great!
 

Invasion of Skaro - ooh, shiny!

And last but very much NOT least,  Nick Hindley's  'Giant Risk' - what a fantastic idea this was! Nick provided the rules  - a 'tweaked' version of the boardgame to add a bit of Napoleonic chrome plus naval elements, ports and forts, all on a single sheet of A4. I took a copy, and hope to be inspired - though perhaps not on such a vast scale.

The terrtitories ( boundaries drawn onto a conventional 'OS' style map of Britain) had been given quirky names - I will forgive him for renaming my bit of East Anglia, as he maintained it was an affectionate term used by his mother, who was born in Ipswich.. 

 

Overall, I think this may just have been  my favourite game of the day! 

All in all, of course a really good lot of games, some really quite spectacular. Maybe a bit  too spectacular? It was interesting to read Neil Patterson's view of the show in his  Aufklarungsabteilung blog - he is of the opinion that these huge showy games with massive trophy terrain pieces have maybe gone too far, in that they are 'demonstration' games demonstrating things that you would be very unlikely to be able to achieve at home or club. I have some sympathy with that view, I admit, and I am rather drawn to the smaller-scale but ingenious games, and those showing an interesting period or foregrounding a particular set of rules - which you might well emulate yourself.  Of course not all the big games are simply static models,  and it's quite inspiring to see large games that are really being played - my favourite example ( albeit not at this show, though they were at May's Partizan ) being the Retired Wargamers Reloaded  Carentan game which I saw at Broadside among other shows, which is clearly being run as a 'real'  game ( using Rapid Fire ) and I think features a different scenario at each outing, on the same basic board.  As long as you keep it simple, large games are entirely possible and quite exciting for a group! Having said that, of course if everyone just brings a bog-standard 'club game', that will be pretty dull -  it's great to see the big games and the amzing terrain, and I was probably guilty of missing a lot of more 'normal' games since I didn't really have time to focus on the 'Participation Zone'  which might have answered a lot of the above questions.Interesting to think about all this,  but I should say emphatically that it was a great show and I thoroughly enjoyed looking at the games I saw.

And now the 'retail therapy' side: there were of course, many traders present and pretty much all your hobby needs could be catered for, but I really only had about half an hour to look around them once we'd looked at the games!  Luckily I didn't go along with a particular shopping list, anyway, and maybe the lack of time was good for concentrating the mind.. As a result I made two purchases : 

(i)  From Kallistra, a set of river/stream hexes should  will be pretty useful in my hex terrain setup:  


(ii) from Helion, I finally took the plunge and acquired my own copy of the late Christopher Duffy's By Force of Arms - so now Chris 'Nundanket' can have his splendid Emperor's Press copy ( very kindly loaned, several months ago ) back! 

 

Well worth getting this, I have been very enjoying reading the loan copy, and I am told the Helion version is a straight re-print, Mr Duffy having not been in sufficient health to produce a revised edition.  Hence  I should be able to simply pick up from where I got to.  Autumn/Winter reading sorted..

I think that sums it up fairly well, a great day had, albeit with a bit too much driving! Thinking about it  I broke a personal cardinal rule, as the journey at 2 hours each way exceeded the actual time ( 3.5 hours - and 45 mins of that was lunch!) that I was able to spend at the show. So next time, I most certainly need to get up much earlier and get there promptly!  (never mind,  next weekend is the good old   SELWG show, and that's a much easier journey).  My thanks to all involved be they  organisers, traders, clubs or players, for making The Other Partizan such a grand day out. 

Next time - well, it will probably be SELWG! Until then keep well, everyone.

14 comments:

  1. Good to see you making the show, David, and catching up with old friends. Your game photos are superb and much enjoyed. Thank you!

    While I agree with Neil's view on demonstration games, modeling, ad wargaming, it is hard not to be impressed by the fantastic castle in Laisot 1785 and the rise of Benoit de Boigne.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon: indeed, as a feat of modelling that fortress was quite something, and it brought a sense of wonder and joy when looking at it! Perhaps fortunately, there is no danger of me ever trying to produce anything similar..

      Delete
  2. Fabulous set of photos David. It’s hard to pick a favourite from my point of view. Sheer patriotism (patrocialism?) means the Grimsby Chums us up there. As well as it being great modelling of course. But that CW game with the impressive Russian column ……that gives a great sense of the size of a division(?). Then there’s the detail of the Indian fortress and the sheer inventiveness of the Risk game.
    Chris/Nundanket

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chris, I admit I thought of you when I saw the Grimsby Chums game. There were many great-looking games there, I'd recommend the show for next year if you are in the area!

      Delete
  3. Great photos Dave. It was a grand day out as Wallace would say and Jacque and I both enjoyed it immensely. Sorry it took you so long to get up there.

    I was interested to read Neil's comments. I think like most commentators, while very impressed with some of the beautiful creations (and some of them were really beautiful - that Indian fortress with monkeys climbing over the battlements, wow) I can see his point about the eye-candy possibly taking centre stage and pushing the more 'normal' games to the margins. Significantly, when telling friends and family about the event I wasn't quite sure whether to use the word 'games' or 'displays' to describe what was going on at those tables. You do start to wonder how much of that is gaming and how much is more about modeling and it would be sad to see gamers pushed out of these events because their setups are seen as less spectacular. Anyway, I hope you enjoy SELWG and I look forward to reading your blog post about that.

    Oh, and I completely missed the unfortunate cow! I guess little details like that, and like the officers dining at a table in the village in the Gainsborough game, are what Neil refers to when he talks about the 'special vignette of Napoleon's haemarroids being treated' - that did make me chuckle.

    Cheers, Dave C.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dave, it was a good day and great to see you both!
      Interesting to see other views e.g. Ray on 'Don't Throw a 1' where they spent more time in the 'Participation Zone', it's a shame we rather ran out of time before getting there. Nothing for it but to go again next year and see that..

      Delete
  4. David,
    Oddly I didn't get to the show until about the same time as you with considerably less distance to travel!
    It was busy, but at least they had opened the all doors by then. In fact I'm sure it would have been possible to just wander in without paying as there was no ticket / stamp / bracelet or anything - I did wonder how you got back in if you went outside!
    I lasted until about 3, but by then had enough.
    Looking at your photos makes me realise again how much I simply missed or walked past without noticing. I think the crowds and noise were taking their toll.
    The display game issue: Aly Morrison reckons most of these games are just people's normal games with a special feature for the show. My response was we move in different circles!
    He of course is no doubt correct as some people show such games on their blogs. While not all of us can do so of course, some lucky talented souls no doubt have games with beautiful figures on outstanding terrain, with a spectacular castle to boot!
    What I do know is that I find the showpiece displays distracting; in most I simply hardly noticed the figures, and in some the number of figures was limited. I suspect this adds to the effect of noticing the terrain above all else. It also possibly explains why I missed so many of the other games as they lacked the visual impact. It's odd how the "different" games stand out - the giant Risk for example.
    I suspect we may have missed each other due to travelling in opposite directions!
    I think I can spot myself in your photo 15 in left rear background by the Caliver stand partly obscured by another punter; the clothes and backpack look about right.
    A comment from Colin of: https://www.carryingsonupthedale.com/2023/10/the-other-partizan.html
    pointed out I appear in one of his photos, unbeknownst to either of us at the time. I appear looking very angry / grumpy in photo 21- the chap in black T shirt by the Gothenburg Gamers sign. Not sure why I look so intimidating but it probably explains why your doppelganger fled when I spoke to him!
    I hope you picked up the Duffy book at a good price; it's worth joining Helion's mailing list as both volumes 1& 2 have been discounted heavily recently.
    Neil

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Neil, I have 'clocked' you now from the 'Carryings on..' blog. It is interesting to see other reports, there are so many games in other people's pictures that I completely missed! I guess that's because there were just an awful lot of games and limited time. I think I missed most of the 'Participation Zone' end of the building, by the time I got there most people were packing up to go home. I will make a point of going there earlier next time...
      I did get a good price on the Duffy book, so I was happy with that (if it had been 'full price' I might have waited until SELWG and looked at other vendors - apologies to Helion!). Chris 'Nundanket' had made me aware of the discount a few weeks ago, and I think I will get on their mailing list.

      Delete
  5. Thanks for all the pics, in particular the Medway game, which doesn’t seem to have many blogs / vids.

    I have a sympathy with the view that the big games don’t always resonate with those gamers who game in domestic settings. A few spectaculars are always nice to champion the hobby, but the symbiotic relationship between the games and the traders is that, the punter gets inspired by the game in a ‘I could do that way’ and then goes off to the trader to buy.

    A few years ago, there was a greater tendency for some traders to also have a demo game on in front of their stall. Peter Pig has always been very good at doing this. At the risk of being plain wrong, I think the only people doing it this year were Anschluss with their WWII stuff. I was hoping Warlord Games would have an Epic table, it is in the brochure, but I have only seen them do it once out of my last 3 shows.

    Arriving at 12.30 does at least see the crows start to thin. I left at 1 and it had become noticeably less busy … though no less noisy :-)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks Norm, glad you enjoyed the pictures. I think Ray at 'Don't Throw a 1' has several more pics of the Medway game, which looked to me slightly 'minimalist' and rather elegant as a result.
    Indeed the 'spectaculars' are good for 'wow' factor and may inspire, but I think I am actually more likely to be inspired by something I can see myself being able to do in my small space and with limited time/budget.
    I'd agree that Peter Pig's demo games always look good, and that Anschluss have taken up that banner - which reminds me I forgot to go and look at their stand - doh!
    And yes, I was never a fan of joining a big queue at the start of the day, letting the crowds reduce a bit is my preference - but it's a balance, against having time to see all the games. Maybe I just need to move a bit faster..

    ReplyDelete
  7. Excellent report and photos. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Some crackin photos David, shame we missed each other, but I'm sure we'll bump into each other before too long.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ray, glad you liked this, and your pics were even better!
      I did see you from a distance near the end of the day, and said hello very briefly to 'Postie'. Never mind, another time!

      Delete