Sunday, 29 October 2023

The Latest Research, 47 Years on

I have been looking around for sources of information on the armies of Alexander the Great and his Persian opponents, so I was quite pleased to find a copy of this book on ebay, at a very reasonable price: 

 

Published by the Wargames Research Group in 1976 ( 47 years ago! ) this is a softback with  60 pages of 'organisation, tactics, dress and weapons. 72 illustrations'.  Phil Barker's introduction states that 'there has to now been a complete lack of specialist publications dealing with ancient armies. This booklet is the first of a series intended to end this situation' - I think it was quite a leap forward at the time. The chapters are Major Battles of the Period,  Tactical Methods,  Composition of Armies, Organisation and Formations, and  Dress and Equipment.  In fact the last of these takes up 3/4 of the book, and that is fine by me. I have very few sources to inspire the painting of my Macedonians and (especially) Persians, so this is may be a help. 

The content is, how shall I say -  brief and to the point. The illustrations are, well, 'basic' springs to mind, and Phil Barker states 'we have not gone in for glossy coloured illustrations for the sake of of prestige, when a black and white sketch with colour notes fulfills the purpose adequately',,, because  'This cuts down on the space required and reduces the expense to the reader'.    

keeping it simple..

What a contrast with the 'eye candy' dominated rulebooks and expansions of today,  they'd never dream of such a philosophy, and you can't charge £30 a pop for that!  ( and this must in effect be the first 'expansion module' , mustn't it?  Readers almost certainly had the WRG Ancients rules, this gave them the details  needed to recruit forces for ths particular period, which Phil terms 'Pike and Elephant' - now why didn't that stick, it's quite  a good label! ).  Thinking around this, it's worth noting that publication date of 1976 - the inflation rate that year was nearly 17%,  having hit 25% the year before!  I can well understand the emphasis on reducing 'the expense to the reader',  publishing anything in that climate must have been a nightmare. Of course it was a success, and it spawned a whole series of related publications, still well-regarded today. Is it possible that today's 'cost of living crisis' may generate a back-to-basics approach and an emphasis on simplicity and low cost? I suppose  Rapid Fire Reloaded springs to mind.. 

I need to think about how to paint my Persians, and this book ( along with the same author's Alexander the Great's Campaigns )  has helped with a few ideas, in particular regarding the lower status Persian troops, who he thinks would be likely to wear costumes made from natural/undyed fabrics. The idea of plainer colours for lower status troops, while the higher status units sport  more colourful finery, works well for me, and may tone down some of the more psychadelic tendencies that can be tempting for Persian armies.. 

Being only 60 pages, I read this in one sitting and am suitably inspired - and of course it features not just Alexandrian and Persian but Indians, Macedonian/Hellenistic Successors, Carthaginians, Republican Romans,  Gallic, Spanish and Numidians, all very tempting for the future. So all in all, I am pleased with my purchase, and also enjoyed opening a little window on wargaming times gone by.  That nostalgic aspect was boosted when I spotted a small label on the back of the book, clearly from a previous seller: 

 



Athena books was of course run by the late great Terry Wise - it's nice to think my copy was probably once in the master's hands.  And it looks like he only wanted £1.50 for it - that must have been quite a long time ago! If books could talk, what tales would this one tell, how many other hands has this been through, and how many armies has it helped to inspire? 

So now with this inspiration,  I need to get the brushes and paints out and raise that Persian army! With luck, some painting progress to report next time. Meanwhile keep well, everyone.

19 comments:

  1. David,
    In an odd bit of synchronicity I've just obtained a replacement copy of that very book from eBay! My original was sold / given away many years ago - the illustrations being coloured in!
    Duncan Head's book is much more academic.....
    Athena Books - there's a blast from the past!
    I bought lots of books and magazines from him as a teenager and wrote to him. He always replied in elegant handwriting, patiently entertaining some callow youth talking nonsense! I wish I stll had the letters, but alas long gone.
    Neil

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Neil, that is a nice coincidence! I bought Terry Wise's Pike and Shot rules from Athena many years ago and was quite inspired by them, still have them and may even give them another try sometime! They gave details of European 30YW armies, not just ECW, which got me started with French and Imperialists. Once he advertised a bit of a clearout sale of his wargames stuff, scenery etc, and I sent my stamped SAE ( sign of the times! ) to get a list. I didn't buy anything in the end, but like you I did rather treasure the handwritten note from him that accompanied the list. Happy days..

      Delete
    2. David,
      Back when I had my 25mm ECW army I eventually settled on Terry Wise's rules. Quite blood thirsty with regard to casualties and I recall the morale was based on losses as a percentage. This meant small units were very brittle. I had a 20 strong cavalry regiment (Rupert's) who could take a lot of punishment. They could happily take on infantry and win due to the way the morale worked.
      Before he died, he started selling off all his assorted wargames collection. I think I bought a few bits and pieces from him but nothing very significant.
      Neil

      Delete
  2. What a great find! Great value - not just because of the contents at a good price, but also because it comes with added nostalgia. What price memories.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chris, yes I was pleased to find this at a reasonable price , it will be useful. And a bonus bit of wargames 'archaeology' attached as well!

      Delete
  3. I do love the old WRG books . I have them still and consult them regularly. Classics that have launched a thousand hobbyists…
    Alan Tradgardland

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Alan, I agree wholeheartedly. I have Tony Bath's campaigns book, and Charles S. Grant's two scenarios books and 'From Pike to Shot' , all from back in the day, and recently acquired 'Armies and Enemies of Imperial Rome'. Always tempting to add to the collection!

      Delete
  4. I never had these first time around (probably didn't even know they exisited, being into WWII at the time) but have bought a few over the years. I love their simple no nonsense approach which just appeals to me: no fluff to pad them out etc. I have the Duncan Head book that is about 190 pages and packed full of info.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Steve, I am in a similar position as did not really look at Ancients much before now. I agree about the 'no frills' approach, it's great. Duncan Head's book looks scarily expensive on-line, you may wish to hang on to that!

      Delete
  5. I, too, enjoy these old WRG books and my library has most of them. My favorite is probably Stillman and Tallis' Armies of the Ancient Near East. Over the years, I have managed to pick up duplicates of many. So, if you are looking for others...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jon, clearly a man of discerning taste! That sounds a very kind offer, which I will bear in mind..

      Delete
  6. What a wonderful back story to your copy of this classic book - priceless.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks MJT, it's funny how these little bits of 'provenance' come up and they always make me wonder - 'if books could talk'.. I hope this one has inspired a few miniature armies in its time!

      Delete
  7. Ahh nostalgia! WRG 3d edition in '73 and converted armies were followed by Minifigs and this gem which also acted as a sort of minifigs catalogue since they followed it quite well. I'd have sworn it was earlier but looking back through the mists of time does often blur things.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ross, I have seen people mention that figure makers often used these books as sources for their desgins - every 'Cretan Archer' tended to have the brimmed hat from the picture here. I think I had the 5th or 6th edition WRG rules, but didn't get lured into large armies by them - George Gush tempted me into Pike and Shot!

      Delete
  8. Great find and a lovely shot of nostalgia!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain, yes nice nostalgia and also both useful and inspiring!

      Delete
  9. Lucky to make such a good find David. Hope it helps.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Richard, I bought it mainly because it looked to be useful, but I admit the nostalgia element was a nice bonus - and I think I was lucky to find it a quite a good price!

      Delete