'Proper Wargaming' : Edgehill with Pike & Shotte

Earlier this week I was fortunate to have a really great day's 'proper wargaming' - thanks to old gaming friends Reg and Tony. We met at Reg's place at Haverhill, which is a nice easy trip for me. Reg had set up his table with his  15mm ECW collection for a re-fight of  Edgehill (1642), the first big battle of the English Civil War. We  used Warlord Games  Pike and Shotte rules, which I had not played before, though I have been introduced to the Warlord  Black Powder system on which P&S is based, in a couple of previous games with the same guys - and I have thoroughly enjoyed playing them.  

I took some pictures during the day, in a slightly haphazard way - as one does when busy playing the game and learning the rules! I'm afraid  some of them are a bit dark, but I'll include a selection  here to give a flavour of the game. Here is the table at the start of the day: 

Initial setup - Parliament to the Left

I should say that nearly all the scenery ( roads, stream, fields, trees etc ) was purely for decoration and did not affect play, except for the hedges at bottom left, lined with Roundhead dragoons. Tony played King Charles,  and Reg and I shared the Parliamentary command, with me on the right (nearest the camera, left of photo)  - each side had two cavalry wings and the central infantry and guns divided into two sub-commands ( called 'Battalia' in the rules, I think - I'd just call them Left and Right Wing of Infantry), so it was easy to split the Parliamentary army.   Reg had put in a few special rules - the main one being aimed at realistic behaviour from the Royalist cavalry.  Prince Rupert over on the Royalist Right ( top right of picture) had 'Galloper' cavalry up against Parliament's less dynamic  horsemen, who used 'Caracole' tactic (they could not counter-charge, which seemed quite a disadvantage) - so Reg made a rule that if the Royalists routed their opponents, they would automatically then have to attack the Parliament baggage train, which was placed nearby. They would fall to looting and be out of the battle, unless actually attacked by further Parliamentary units. That seemed quite an appropriate rule, and I'm sure we all assumed it would happen - more on that, later! 

For obvious reasons, I was more involved and took more pictures of my side of the battlefield, which was perhaps a shame, as the really decisive action took place over on the other wing, as Reg's horse  battled with Tony/Rupert's Cavaliers!  Anyway, here's my cavalry wing  ( slightly better quality, as I had 'Gallopers'),  and the foot beyond: 

Parliament right-wing cavalry

   and my opponents on the Royalist left :

 Reg's figures were fairly 'vintage' ( I mean that in the nicest possible way) and included both 'second generation'  and 'third generation' Minifigs 15s - I have some of the '2nd Gen' myself, and I rather like them, I think they are  well-proportioned, crisply-sculpted and simple.  And  I reckon they were from the early 1980s, so 'vintage' indeed!  

Over on our left wing,  here are Reg's sturdy 'Caracolers'  moving up steadily:

Parliament left-wing cavalry 

 ..and here are a couple of Rupert's regiments coming in at the gallop ( or maybe 'a good round trot' at least) 

..vs. Rupert's Cavaliers 

 

To give an idea of how things developed, here's an overview of the battle, about the mid-point of the day : 

 Reg and I pretty much stood our ground and let Tony come to fight us - Tony attacked on both wings with his cavalry as expected, and used an interesting manouevre in the centre. He brought forward  most of his second line infantry units into the first line, hence coming at us with just one line  of infantry, and aiming to get superior numbers into action early on and overpower our first line ( not having moved forward much, we didn't have space to imiitate him, but equally I was happy to be more 'conventional' and keep the second line as reserves to feed into the fight as required.  Tony also came forward in something of an 'oblique order', having spotted that my cavalry wing was not going to advance beyond the hedgeline, so would not threaten his infantry flank, therefore  his left-wing foot could move further forward.  

The cavalry wings got stuck in, but not perhaps as expected. It's got to be said that Rupert had something of a bad day! As Reg likes to say, his favourite part of the Black Powder system is the 'Command Rolls',  required to allow units and groups of units to carry out their orders. A very simple die-roll mechanism means you just can't be sure if your orders will be carried out - and I think failures can easily be rationalised as due to messengers not getting through, orders being misunderstood, or regimental commanders being indecisive, incompetent or perhaps even drunk! Anyway for whatever reason, 'Rupert' had quite a lot of problems getting his splendid horsemen to dash forward - he wasn't alone as his opponent had quite a few failed rolls as well! Instead of the expected Royalist steamroller going over the Parliamentary wing, things developed in an much more back-and-forth way. Reg's cavalry could not counter-charge but there was nothing stopping them just charging, and they managed that well enough several times! Quite a classic 'whirling cavalry fight' developed, as you can see here 

Cavalry fight on Rupert's wing - not the expected walkover!

Reg used a simple token system for keeping track of unit status - the 'puffs of smoke' indicated Disordered units, the small green dice were for tracking casualties , and when a unit took enough hits to  reach 'shaken' status the green die was placed on a circular mdf token. So you can see the nearest unit in the picture ( Royalists) is looking rather battered! 

On my cavalry wing, I was well-cast as a cautious early Roundhead leader, deciding to hold the hedge line with my cavalry if possible, thus negating any charge bonus for the other side. Tony wasn't dicouraged by that, and got stuck in of course! We tussled long and hard over those hedges, but I'm glad to say my chaps held their ground, and the Royalists could not break us. Here's a typical melee across the hedge, with the larger red dice used to keep track of hits taken in the melee ( which may of course be 'saved'  before translating to the green casualty dice ).  Looks like my chaps (left) are getting the better of this one, just!   

 

I have to say I managed to miss photographing the most exciting incident on my wing - isn;t that always the way, too busy rolling the dice and reacting to the results! I got a bit complacent and moved one of my central foot regiments forward ( I had been maintaining an alignment with the hedges overall), and they were pounced on by Tony, who sent a cavalry unit galloping hell-for-leather to attack them in the flank  - aided by a highly successful 'up to three moves' command roll!  My regiment was able to go into 'hedgehog', and in fact the Cavaliers never made contact, as they had charged across the front of another Parliamentary regiment and a gun, who all fired like crazy - the horse took enough hits to force a Break Test, which sent them reeling back to their own lines.  They did however have an impact, as the poor Parliament infantry unit was now stuck in 'Hedgehog' and shot to pieces by Royalist foot and guns!

Infantry firefight on the Parliament centre left 

 All along the line the infantry and guns carried on firefights, with plenty of casualties taken and dished out, and Tony's tactic of bringing forward more units came close to working - at one point Reg had three adjacent units all teetering on the edge of breaking, which would have left a massive hole in our centre!  Lucky for us, Tony's next round of firing saw some low die-rolls, Reg was able to rally off some losses and we breathed again! 

and on our centre right 

 Above is my side of the infantry fight, and you can see where a first-line unit had routed under fire, but I was able to feed a second-line regiment into the gap - that felt like authentic tactics. 

Allowing for a lunch break etc,  I reckon we got about five hours of solid gaming in, and it was always absorbing and fun, thanks to my fellow players and the very 'playable' rules.  And the result? Well, on my flank we held those hedges fairly well, and didn't look like we'd be shifted; in the centre there had been fiercesome firefights but no-one had actually closed to 'push of pike', and things looked pretty evenly matched.  But on our left wing, Rupert's Cavaliers actually took quite a bashing from the Parliamentary horse, and I think in the end Rupert's wing lost half its units, and was therefore 'Broken' - quite the opposite result to what I had assumed! That left Reg with enough cavalry in good shape to start rolling up the Royalist foot on our left ( and remember they had advanced in a single line, no reserves - that may have been a fateful decision! ).  So at that point, and with an  appointment for dinner at the local pub, Tony graciously conceded, and 'twas a famous victory for Parliament!  Below you can see the final situation and my excellent fellow players :

 That was a great day's gaming!  Many thanks to Reg for hosting, great figures and table  and  a really good scenario, and Tony for his usual cunning and dynamic play, and all in a great friendly spirit!

We all had some thoughts on the game - we did wonder if the artillery were a bit too powerful, not so much due to the rules,  but perhaps there were too many guns? Both sides were  a little reluctant to charge their foot forward into melee, partly due to the expected effects of close-range guns on the chargers. I have Peter Young's book on the battle somewhere, and am interested to have a look at the OOBs and the numbers of guns.   I wondered if we had also set up a little too far apart - we had both light and medium guns, and both had to move forward slightly to get into range. I think historically the armies deployed within artillery range, and the battle opened with an exchange of cannon shot, as was typical at the time. So perhaps we should have started a bit closer, and given at least the medium guns the chance to shoot from the start, rather than the first couple of moves being taken up with shuffling forward into range. 

The rules, I thoroughly enjoyed - I've talked about about the command rolls, and I do think they are a very neat way of introducing 'friction' to proceedings, in a reasonably authentic way - note that a better commander will succeed with his orders more often, and your C-in-C has the opportunity to 're-roll' some of your failures, which allows you some more agency.   The firing and combat rules are really simple 'roll a bunch of D6', with generally 4,5 or 6 to hit, the opposition allowed saving rolls and the crucial '6 inflicts temporary disorder', which gives a further level of uncertainty - you might save all those hits, but still be disordered by the enemy fire.  As a beginner I didn't get all the concepts and mechanics  straight away, but certainly picked up enough to be playing quite happily, pretty quickly. Reg and Tony are big fans of rhe Warlord BP system, and I can entirely see why ( I just noticed Norm Smith his excellent Commanders web page giving a great little run-through of how the system works for a Napoleonic infantry 'column vs. line' assault - see  'A Run Out With Black Powder', 25th Aug 2025 - , he is clearly a fan too!).   Now I must say that from pure cussedness I think I am not going to get entangled in the Warlord 'universe' and start buying all the multiple editions and formats of rulebooks and scenario books and starter sets, but I'm more than happy to play them as a guest; might even look out for a second-hand set of 'BP' on ebay or whatever, just to be a bit more prepared in future!  

All in all, a really good day's gaming, in good company - many thanks indeed to both Reg and Tony. I look foward to further outings - hmm, it may be my turn to host next, and those recently-acquired 7YW figures might be useful..  I hope this has been interesting for readers, it was certainly enjoyable for me, both to play and to write about.    

Next time, I may be able to present some sort of 'parade' of vntage Minfigs 25mms. Until then, keep well, everyone.